Are 24 phrase Bitcoin seed phrases higher than 12 phrases for safety?

On the coronary heart of crypto pockets safety lies the seed phrase, a string of phrases that serves because the grasp key to accessing and recovering digital property. Whereas each 12-word and 24-word seed phrases are generally used, the variations of their safety implications have been debated inside the crypto group.

The 12-word seed phrase offers 128 bits of entropy and has been the usual for a lot of crypto wallets. This stage of entropy interprets to an astronomical variety of doable mixtures, making it extremely proof against brute-force assaults with present know-how. In distinction, 24-word seed phrases supply 256 bits of entropy, doubling the theoretical safety.

Nevertheless, the sensible safety achieve from utilizing a 24-word phrase over a 12-word one shouldn’t be as substantial because the numbers recommend. The efficient safety of Bitcoin’s elliptic curve cryptography (secp256k1) is 128 bits. Because of this whatever the seed phrase size, an attacker can’t cut back the variety of steps required to calculate a personal key from a public key beneath this threshold.

12 phrases is sufficient

Adam Again, a outstanding cryptographer and CEO of Blockstream, has advocated for the sufficiency of 12-word seeds, stating that they supply ample safety for many customers. The shift in direction of 24-word phrases in some {hardware} wallets, similar to Trezor, was primarily pushed by particular implementation necessities moderately than a urgent want for enhanced safety.

The actual safety problem typically lies not within the size of the seed phrase however in how customers retailer and shield it. Each 12-word and 24-word phrases are susceptible to phishing assaults, bodily theft, and person error in storage. A securely saved 12-word phrase is much more practical than a carelessly dealt with 24-word one.

From a person expertise perspective, 12-word phrases supply distinct benefits. They’re simpler to write down down, bear in mind, and enter, lowering the probability of errors throughout pockets restoration processes. This simplicity may be essential in high-stress conditions the place customers must entry their funds shortly.

Whereas 24-word phrases do present the next stage of theoretical safety, the sensible advantages within the context of present cryptographic requirements are marginal. The extra complexity they introduce could even result in elevated person errors, probably compromising safety.

Utilizing 24-word phrases is likely to be justified as an additional precautionary measure for institutional or high-value accounts. Nevertheless, a correctly secured 12-word seed phrase gives greater than ample safety in opposition to potential threats for the typical person.

The place 24 phrases could also be higher

Wei Dai, a famend cryptographer and creator of b-money, gives a nuanced perspective on the safety implications of seed phrase lengths. He emphasizes that whereas a 12-word seed phrase (128 bits of entropy) is theoretically ample for single-user safety when hashed to a 256-bit key, the state of affairs modifications dramatically in a multi-user setting.

Dai factors out that this building can solely help as much as 2^64 keys earlier than risking collisions, a limitation that turns into important in real-world deployments the place tens of millions of customers generate wallets. His perception illustrates the significance of contemplating concrete safety bounds and extra complete safety fashions that transcend single-user situations.

Because the crypto ecosystem evolves, so do the safety measures surrounding it. Some pockets suppliers now supply customizable entropy choices, permitting customers to decide on between 12, 18, or 24 phrases based mostly on their private safety preferences and threat assessments. Choices similar to Shamir Secret Sharing are additionally obtainable on some {hardware} wallets utilizing 20 or 33 phrases.

In the end, the selection between a 12-word and 24-word seed phrase ought to be based mostly on a person’s particular wants, technical consolation stage, and threat profile. Whereas the longer phrase could supply a psychological sense of elevated safety, customers ought to do not forget that essentially the most essential think about defending their digital property is their seed phrase’s cautious dealing with and storage, no matter its size.

Schooling on greatest practices for seed phrase administration stays essential. Whether or not choosing 12, 18, 20, 24, or 33 phrases, customers should prioritize safe storage strategies, similar to offline backups and {hardware} wallets, to make sure the protection of their digital property in an more and more complicated digital panorama.

Talked about on this article